Only Murders in the Building Season 5: Martin Short's Hints, Release Date, and Theories

Sep 09, 2025

Only Murders in the Building Season 5: Is It Really Happening?

The Arconia is never quiet for long. After a riveting fourth season of Only Murders in the Building, fans are clamoring for more mysteries, more mayhem, and more of the delightfully dysfunctional trio of Charles-Haden Savage (Steve Martin), Oliver Putnam (Martin Short), and Mabel Mora (Selena Gomez). While official announcements from Hulu have been scarce, a certain Martin Short has dropped some intriguing hints, fueling speculation about a potential Season 5. But what do we really know, what can we expect, and when might we return to our favorite Upper West Side apartment building?

Martin Short's Cryptic Clues: What Did He Say?

The spark of hope for Season 5 was ignited by none other than the comedic genius himself, Martin Short. While details remain vague and tantalizingly elusive, Short has mentioned in interviews and public appearances that conversations are underway regarding future seasons. He hasn't confirmed a definitive Season 5 greenlight, but his statements strongly suggest that the possibility is very much on the table. Specific quotes often focus on the creative team's enthusiasm and desire to continue exploring the characters and the unique world they inhabit. This, combined with the show's consistent popularity, points towards a high likelihood of a renewal.

He hasn’t been explicit, deliberately so. Part of the show’s charm is the secrecy surrounding each season. However, experienced observers of entertainment news understand that even carefully crafted ambiguity can signal positive developments.

Analyzing the Hints: Deciphering the Subtext

Let’s dissect Short's hints and consider their implications:

Conversations are underway: This indicates that Hulu and the show's creators are actively discussing the future of Only Murders in the Building. It’s beyond the initial idea stage.
Enthusiasm from the creative team: This is crucial. A show's longevity depends heavily on the passion of its writers, producers, and actors. If they're eager to continue, it significantly increases the chances of renewal.
Focus on character development: This suggests that the writers have more stories to tell about Charles, Oliver, and Mabel, delving deeper into their personalities and relationships.

While these hints aren't a guarantee, they paint a promising picture. The key takeaway is that the decision to continue Only Murders in the Building rests on factors beyond just ratings. Creative satisfaction and ongoing narrative possibilities are equally important.

Season 5: Release Date Predictions and Potential Timelines

Predicting release dates in the television industry is always a tricky endeavor, especially when official announcements are pending. However, we can analyze the release patterns of previous seasons to formulate a reasonable estimate for Only Murders in the Building Season 5.

Looking Back: Past Release Dates as a Guide

Here's a breakdown of the release dates for the first four seasons:

Season 1: August 31, 2021
Season 2: June 28, 2022
Season 3: August 8, 2023
Season 4: August 27, 2024

As you can see, there's a general trend of new seasons premiering in the late summer months (June-August). This timeframe likely aligns with Hulu's programming schedule and allows for sufficient production time between seasons.

Potential Release Window for Season 5

Based on past patterns, a realistic release window for Only Murders in the Building Season 5 would be late summer 2025 (July-August). This assumes that the show is officially renewed soon and that production proceeds without any major delays. Factors that could affect the timeline include:

Scriptwriting and pre-production: The writing process, casting new characters, and securing filming locations can take several months.
Filming schedule: The actual filming of the season can be a lengthy process, especially considering the show's intricate plot and ensemble cast.
Post-production: Editing, sound design, and visual effects all contribute to the final product and require significant time and effort.
Availability of the cast: Coordinating the schedules of Steve Martin, Martin Short, and Selena Gomez, all of whom have busy careers, can present logistical challenges.

It's also important to remember that unforeseen circumstances, such as the WGA strike which impacted the television industry in 2023, can disrupt production schedules. As such, it's always best to take release date predictions with a grain of salt until official confirmation is provided.

Theories and Speculation: What Mysteries Await in Season 5?

The beauty of Only Murders in the Building lies in its ability to surprise and delight viewers with unexpected twists and turns. As we eagerly await news of Season 5, the internet is abuzz with fan theories and speculation about what mysteries might unfold in the Arconia. Let's delve into some of the most intriguing possibilities:

The Case of the Vanishing Artifact

One popular theory centers around a valuable artifact that goes missing from the Arconia. Perhaps it's a priceless painting, a rare antique, or a historical document. The theft could be connected to a new resident with a hidden agenda, or it could involve a long-forgotten secret buried within the building's walls.

This storyline offers several exciting possibilities:

A closed circle of suspects: Restricting the suspects to the Arconia's residents would maintain the show's signature intimate setting and allow for deeper character exploration.
Red herrings and misdirection: The writers could cleverly mislead the audience with false clues and deceptive characters, keeping viewers guessing until the very end.
A connection to the Arconia's history: The missing artifact could be linked to a significant event in the building's past, revealing new secrets and surprising connections.

The Return of a Familiar Face… with a Dark Secret

Another compelling theory involves the return of a character from a previous season, but with a sinister twist. Perhaps a seemingly innocent resident is revealed to have a dark secret, or a former suspect resurfaces with a new motive for revenge.

Consider these possibilities:

Jan (Amy Ryan): Could Jan escape prison and seek revenge on Charles for exposing her? Her manipulative personality and cunning nature make her a formidable adversary.
Cinda Canning (Tina Fey): What if Cinda is not just an opportunistic podcaster, but a mastermind pulling strings behind the scenes? Her ambition and ruthless tactics could lead her down a dangerous path.
A surprising ally turned enemy: Perhaps a character who initially helped Charles, Oliver, and Mabel is revealed to have ulterior motives, betraying their trust and jeopardizing their safety.

A Mystery Beyond the Arconia's Walls

While Only Murders in the Building is primarily set within the confines of the Arconia, Season 5 could explore a mystery that extends beyond the building's walls. Perhaps a crime committed in the outside world has unexpected connections to the Arconia, drawing Charles, Oliver, and Mabel into a dangerous investigation.

This could involve:

A conspiracy with city-wide implications: The trio could uncover a web of corruption and deceit that reaches the highest levels of power.
A case that forces them to leave their comfort zone: Charles, Oliver, and Mabel might have to venture into unfamiliar territory, encountering new challenges and unexpected allies.
A personal connection to the victim: The victim of the crime could be someone with a close connection to one of the main characters, adding a personal stake to the investigation.

The Cast and Crew: Who's Likely to Return?

The success of Only Murders in the Building hinges on the chemistry and talent of its core cast and creative team. While official casting announcements are pending for Season 5, it's highly likely that the following individuals will return:

The Core Trio: Martin, Short, and Gomez

Of course, the heart and soul of the show are Steve Martin, Martin Short, and Selena Gomez. Their dynamic as Charles, Oliver, and Mabel is what makes Only Murders in the Building so endearing and entertaining. Without them, the show simply wouldn't be the same. Their return is almost guaranteed, barring unforeseen circumstances.

Key Supporting Characters

In addition to the main trio, several supporting characters have become integral to the show's fabric. Here are a few who we can expect to see again:

Howard Morris (Michael Cyril Creighton): The quirky and lovable Arconia resident, Howard's nervous energy and penchant for gossip always add a comedic touch to the show.
Uma Heller (Jackie Hoffman): The sharp-tongued and opinionated board member of the Arconia, Uma's presence always guarantees some memorable moments.
Detective Williams (Da'Vine Joy Randolph): The no-nonsense detective who has assisted Charles, Oliver, and Mabel in their investigations, Williams provides a grounded and realistic perspective to the show.

The Creative Team Behind the Magic

The creative vision of the show's writers, producers, and directors is just as important as the cast. We can expect to see the return of:

John Hoffman (Co-creator and showrunner): Hoffman's leadership and creative direction have been instrumental in the show's success.
Steve Martin (Co-creator, writer, and actor): Martin's comedic genius and writing skills are essential to the show's unique tone and humor.
Dan Fogelman (Executive producer): Fogelman's experience as a successful television producer (This Is Us) brings valuable expertise to the show.

Why We Love Only Murders in the Building: The Show's Enduring Appeal

Only Murders in the Building has captivated audiences worldwide with its unique blend of mystery, comedy, and heart. But what is it about this show that has resonated so deeply with viewers? Let's explore some of the key factors that contribute to its enduring appeal:

A Clever Combination of Genres

The show masterfully blends elements of the mystery, comedy, and dramedy genres. It delivers a compelling whodunit plot while also providing plenty of laughs and moments of genuine emotion. This combination appeals to a wide range of viewers, making it accessible and enjoyable for everyone.

Relatable Characters with Flaws and Quirks

Charles, Oliver, and Mabel are not perfect heroes. They have their flaws, insecurities, and eccentricities. This makes them relatable and believable, allowing viewers to connect with them on a personal level. We root for them because we see ourselves in them.

A Nostalgic Nod to Classic Mystery Stories

Only Murders in the Building pays homage to classic mystery stories, such as Agatha Christie novels and film noir movies. The show incorporates familiar tropes and conventions of the genre while also adding its own modern twist. This nostalgic element appeals to fans of traditional mysteries while also attracting new viewers.

A Celebration of Community and Connection

At its core, Only Murders in the Building is a story about community and connection. Charles, Oliver, and Mabel find solace and purpose in their shared passion for true crime and their friendship with each other. The show reminds us of the importance of human connection and the power of community in overcoming challenges.

The Allure of True Crime Podcasts

The show taps into the current obsession with true crime podcasts. The characters' decision to start their own podcast adds a meta-narrative layer to the show, commenting on the popularity and ethics of the true crime genre. It also provides a framework for the storytelling, allowing the audience to follow the investigation in real-time.

Beyond Season 5: The Future of Only Murders in the Building

While we're eagerly anticipating news of Season 5, it's worth considering the long-term future of Only Murders in the Building. How many more seasons can we expect? What new directions might the show take?

Potential Season Count

It's difficult to predict the exact number of seasons that Only Murders in the Building will ultimately have. However, given the show's consistent popularity and the creative team's enthusiasm, it's reasonable to expect at least a few more seasons beyond Season 5. Many successful television shows run for five to seven seasons, and Only Murders in the Building has the potential to reach that milestone.

Exploring New Mysteries and Settings

While the Arconia has been the primary setting for the show, there's always the possibility of exploring new mysteries and locations in future seasons. The characters could embark on a new investigation in a different city, or they could uncover a hidden secret within the Arconia that leads them to unexpected places.

Introducing New Characters and Relationships

The show could also introduce new characters and relationships to keep the dynamic fresh and exciting. Perhaps Charles, Oliver, and Mabel will form new alliances with other residents of the Arconia, or they will encounter intriguing individuals who challenge their perspectives and beliefs.

Evolving Character Arcs and Personal Growth

As the show progresses, it's important for the characters to continue to evolve and grow. Charles, Oliver, and Mabel have already undergone significant transformations since the beginning of the series, and their personal journeys should continue to be explored in future seasons. Perhaps they will confront their past traumas, pursue new ambitions, or find new love interests.

The Wait Begins: Staying Patient and Savoring the Anticipation

The wait for official news regarding Only Murders in the Building Season 5 may feel long, but it's important to remember that these things take time. The creative team needs to develop a compelling story, secure the necessary resources, and coordinate the schedules of the cast and crew. In the meantime, we can savor the anticipation and speculate about what mysteries await us in the Arconia.

We can also revisit our favorite episodes from previous seasons, re-listen to the Only Murders in the Building podcast, and engage with other fans online. The community surrounding this show is passionate and dedicated, and there are plenty of ways to stay connected and share our enthusiasm. The more buzz there is about the show, the more likely a renewal becomes.

When the official announcement finally arrives, it will be all the more satisfying. And when Season 5 premieres, we can all gather together once again to solve another mystery, laugh at the antics of Charles, Oliver, and Mabel, and celebrate the enduring power of Only Murders in the Building.

Conclusion: The Future Looks Bright for Only Murders in the Building

While nothing is officially confirmed, the hints from Martin Short, combined with the show's consistent success and the creative team's enthusiasm, strongly suggest that Only Murders in the Building Season 5 is a highly likely prospect. We can expect a potential release in late summer 2025, and a whole new set of mysteries to unravel in the iconic Arconia building. The blend of comedy, mystery, and heartfelt character development continues to resonate with audiences, making the show a beloved staple of Hulu's lineup. So, keep your ears open for more news, because the Murders are likely just getting started!