Buffalo Bills 2023 NFL Draft: Complete Analysis & Depth Chart Impact

Published on: Apr 25, 2025

The Buffalo Bills entered the 2023 NFL Draft with a clear objective: solidify their already impressive roster and address potential weaknesses to make a Super Bowl push. Their draft strategy, a blend of addressing immediate needs and securing long-term talent, provided intriguing insights into the team's vision. Let's delve into a comprehensive analysis of each pick and its impact on the Bills' depth chart.

Round 1, Pick 27: Dalton Kincaid, TE, Utah

The selection of Dalton Kincaid, a highly talented tight end from Utah, immediately addressed a need for a versatile pass-catching weapon. Kincaid's impressive route-running ability and soft hands make him a perfect complement to Dawson Knox, providing the Bills with a dynamic duo at the tight end position. This pick significantly boosts their offensive potential, adding another dimension to Josh Allen's arsenal. Kincaid’s impact is expected to be felt immediately, potentially pushing veteran tight end Quintin Morris down the depth chart.

Kincaid's Depth Chart Impact:

  • Starter Potential: While Knox remains the clear starter, Kincaid's talent could lead to a two-tight-end formation, significantly expanding offensive play-calling options.
  • Red Zone Threat: Kincaid's size and ability to high-point the ball make him a major threat in the red zone, a critical area for the Bills' offense.
  • Competition for Snaps: His presence will create healthy competition amongst tight ends for playing time, pushing everyone to perform at their best.

Round 2, Pick 59: Trenton Simpson, LB, Clemson

Adding Trenton Simpson in the second round signified a commitment to strengthening their linebacker corps. Simpson's blend of athleticism and instincts make him an ideal fit for Sean McDermott's defensive scheme. While not a pure run-stopper, Simpson’s versatility to cover and blitz allows him to excel in today’s NFL. The selection of Simpson adds depth and competition at linebacker, enhancing the team's ability to defend against both the run and pass.

Simpson's Depth Chart Impact:

  • Competition for Matt Milano: Simpson will likely compete with Matt Milano for snaps at linebacker, creating a healthy competitive environment.
  • Special Teams Contribution: Simpson’s athleticism translates to significant contributions on special teams immediately.
  • Future Starter Potential: Simpson has the talent to potentially become a future starter for the Bills, ensuring long-term depth at the position.

Round 3, Pick 91: O'Cyrus Torrence, OG, Florida

The Bills addressed their offensive line with the selection of O'Cyrus Torrence. Torrence brings impressive size and power, strengthening the interior offensive line. He is expected to add immediate depth and potentially compete for a starting guard position. His addition provides crucial insurance and reinforces the Bills' commitment to protecting Josh Allen.

Torrence's Depth Chart Impact:

  • Competition for Starting Guard Spot: Torrence will directly challenge for a starting role, pushing the incumbents to improve their performance.
  • Backup Offensive Line Depth: His addition solidifies the Bills' depth along the offensive line, providing much-needed insurance against injuries.
  • Long-Term Solution: Torrence is seen as a potential long-term solution at guard, offering stability to the offensive line for years to come.

Round 4, Pick 130: James Cook's Backup

While the Bills didn't make a high-profile pick at this position in the 2023 Draft, they likely aimed to fill a gap in the backfield depth chart. Drafting a player in this round focuses on developing a player who could learn under the existing veterans and offer support in the future. This allows them to focus their higher-round picks on more pressing needs while still adding potential depth and competition to this role.

Round 5, Pick 161: Additional Depth

Later-round picks often focus on adding depth and developing raw talent. The Bills' fifth-round pick likely focused on filling a specific need or adding a player with high upside who needs further development within their system. These players add value by improving the overall depth of the team.

Round 7, Pick 230: Project Player

Seventh-round selections are typically considered long shots. The Bills likely took a chance on a player with high potential who needs significant development. These selections are low-risk, high-reward, offering a chance to find a hidden gem that can contribute down the line.

Overall Draft Impact on the Bills' Depth Chart:

The Buffalo Bills' 2023 NFL Draft was strategically sound, adding significant depth and competition at key positions. The additions of Kincaid, Simpson, and Torrence provide immediate boosts to the offensive and defensive sides of the ball. The later-round selections aim to build depth and develop potential contributors. This overall strategy aims to strengthen the team for a Super Bowl run, filling gaps and promoting competition within the existing roster. The draft success will depend on how these rookies integrate into the team dynamic and their individual development throughout the season.

Addressing Future Needs:

While the 2023 draft addressed immediate needs, the Bills remain aware of future roster needs. Maintaining depth at critical positions and proactively identifying potential weaknesses will continue to shape their off-season strategies. Scouting talent throughout the year and carefully analyzing player performance will be paramount. Their approach to the draft demonstrates a long-term perspective focused on sustained success.

Conclusion:

The Buffalo Bills' 2023 NFL Draft displayed a smart and focused approach, adding crucial talent and enhancing the depth of their already impressive roster. The success of their draft will ultimately be measured by these players' performance on the field, but the initial impact suggests a positive outcome that increases the Bills' chances of securing their ultimate goal: a Super Bowl victory. The combination of high-impact early picks and calculated depth additions positions the Bills to be highly competitive throughout the upcoming season.